Details
Disproof attempts, all failed: (a) that a later release closed the afterSanitize gap, refuted by inspecting the published 3.4.13, 3.4.14, and 3.4.15 artifacts; (b) that detached descendants are revisited or re-sanitized, refuted at runtime (the onerror is retained only at the afterSanitize sites and stripped at the before/upon sites and with no removal hook); (c) that the post-walk pass catches hook-detached nodes, refuted by the design that excludes them from DOMPurify.removed; (d) that the precondition is contrived, refuted by parity with the accepted GHSA-55q2 threat model and the library's own supported pattern of removing a node inside afterSanitizeElements. The only edge not directly executed is the browser resource-event dispatch (jsdom performs no real image load); it is established by the proven retention of the live handler after a synchronous return, the library's own comments describing exactly this hazard, and parity with the accepted GHSA-55q2 mechanism.
Affected Versions
Ecosystem: npmPackage: dompurifyConfirmed affected range: >= 3.4.13, <= 3.4.15Latest release checked: 3.4.15 (npm registry)Fix status: fixed in 3.4.16
The before/upon detach neutralization introduced for GHSA-55q2-fjhq-7xh7 first shipped in 3.4.13; the residual afterSanitize gap was verified by reproducing it against the published npm artifacts for 3.4.13, 3.4.14, and 3.4.15. The 3.4.12 artifact predates that neutralization and behaves differently at the before/upon sites, so it is outside this specific incomplete-fix range. No release through 3.4.15 neutralizes detached subtrees at the afterSanitize sites, so no fixed version is established.
Suggested Fix
Enforce the same IN_PLACE detach-neutralization invariant at every hook site that can detach a node, not only the before/upon sites. Concretely, apply a _handleHookDetachedNode(currentNode, root) re-check after afterSanitizeElements at both src/purify.ts:2208 and 2249 (returning as removed when the node was detached), and add an equivalent IN_PLACE detach check plus _neutralizeSubtree after afterSanitizeAttributes at 2670. As an interim mitigation without a code change, applications using IN_PLACE can avoid removing nodes inside afterSanitizeElements/afterSanitizeAttributes hooks and instead perform such removals in beforeSanitizeElements/uponSanitizeElement, or avoid IN_PLACE for attacker-influenced content.
Reported by zx (GitHub: @manus-pi).