Advisory

GHSA-wr5r-wqp2-x4fh

Also known as: CVE-2026-63669

Summary

ApostropheCMS: Missing destination-parent authorization in page move() allows a low-privileged editor to move and re-rank pages inside a restricted subtree

Details

Summary
ApostropheCMS enforces per-type authorization on pages: a page type may declare editRole / publishRole (and the core @apostrophecms/archive-page does), so a project can have page-type subtrees that only higher-privileged roles are allowed to create or edit within. The move() operation is supposed to enforce that a page may only be moved *into* a parent the actor has create rights over — this is the same boundary the page-insert route enforces (the insert target is fetched with .permission('create')).

A regression in the move authorization guard silently disabled that destination check for every normal move. The guard now reads (oldParent._id !== parent._id) && (parent.type !== '@apostrophecms/archive-page') && (!parent._create) && (oldParent.type === '@apostrophecms/archive-page' && !parent._edit). Because the final && clause requires oldParent.type === '@apostrophecms/archive-page', the whole conjunction can only be true while restoring a page *out of the archive*. For any ordinary move (the source page's old parent is a normal page), that clause is false, the entire condition is false, and !parent._create is never evaluated. The only surviving gate in the whole path is moved._edit — i.e. "can the actor edit the page being moved", which a low-privileged editor legitimately holds for their own ordinary pages.

The result is that any authenticated user who can edit at least one page can relocate that page under a parent of a restricted type they have no create/edit rights over, and in doing so trigger an unauthenticated, unchecked updateMany that re-ranks the restricted parent's existing children (documents the actor cannot edit). This is reachable directly from the documented PATCH/PUT /api/v1/@apostrophecms/page/:_id REST routes via the attacker-controlled _targetId / _position body fields.

Affected code (4.31.0)

The broken guard in move() — packages/apostrophe/modules/@apostrophecms/page/index.js:

if (!moved._edit) {
  throw self.apos.error('forbidden');
}
if (!(parent && oldParent)) {
  // Move outside tree
  throw self.apos.error('forbidden');
}
if (
  (oldParent._id !== parent._id) &&
  (parent.type !== '@apostrophecms/archive-page') &&
  (!parent._create) &&
  (oldParent.type === '@apostrophecms/archive-page' && !parent._edit)   // <-- regression: gates the whole check on "moving out of the archive"
) {
  throw self.apos.error('forbidden');
}

The target/parent is fetched with permission filtering explicitly OFF (so the guard above is the *only* thing that is supposed to enforce destination authorization) — getTarget():

const target = await self.findForEditing(_req, criteria)
  .permission(false)        // target is located regardless of the actor's rights
  .archived(null)
  .areas(false)
  .ancestors({ depth: 1, ... permission: false })
  .children({ depth: 1, ... permission: false }).toObject();

The privileged sink that then runs unguarded — nudgeNewPeers() re-ranks the destination parent's existing children with a raw DB write and no permission check:

async function nudgeNewPeers() {
  const locale = moved.aposLocale.split(':')[0];
  const criteria = {
    path: self.matchDescendants(parent),
    aposLocale: { $in: [ `${locale}:draft`, `${locale}:published` ] },
    level: parent.level + 1,
    rank: { $gte: rank }
  };
  // Nudge down the pages that should now follow us
  await self.apos.doc.db.updateMany(criteria, { $inc: { rank: 1 } });
  ...
}

The REST entry point — the patch route reaches move() after only the moved._edit gate, with attacker-controlled _targetId / _position:

const page = await self.findOneForEditing(req, { _id });
...
if (!page._edit) {
  throw self.apos.error('forbidden');
}
...
if (input._targetId) {
  const targetId = self.apos.launder.string(input._targetId);
  const position = self.apos.launder.string(input._position);
  modified = await self.move(req, page._id, targetId, position);
}

For comparison, the sibling page-insert route enforces the destination boundary correctly by fetching the target with create-permission filtering, so an actor without create rights under the target gets notfound:

// post route (insert)
const target = await self.getTarget(req, ...).permission('create') ... // restricted target is not found -> insert denied

Provenance (introduced regression)
The guard was correct until commit 9f72bd229be07e537a2ae894f4527f2fe6bcd3bd ("allow restore pages"), which changed it from (oldParent._id !== parent._id) && (parent.type !== '@apostrophecms/archive-page') && (!parent._create) to the four-clause version above. The intent was to stop legitimate *archive restores* (where parent._create can be false) from being wrongly forbidden, but ANDing the new clause onto the existing chain gated the entire _create enforcement on oldParent being the archive — silently removing destination authorization for all normal moves. The condition is unchanged at HEAD (4.31.0).

Attacker model / precondition
The attacker is a low-privileged but content-editing authenticated user — in the core role model an editor or (in draft mode) a contributor — who can edit at least one ordinary page. No admin rights, no special tokens.

The differentiated-permission boundary that makes this a *bypass* must exist in the project. In core, permission.can(req, 'create'/'edit', type) is computed per page-type via checkRoleConfig('editRole'), so the boundary is present whenever a project configures a page type (or the archive) with an editRole / publishRole higher than the actor's role, or uses per-page editPermission / the @apostrophecms/workflow add-on to make _edit / _create page-specific. The core @apostrophecms/archive-page already ships editRole: 'admin' / publishRole: 'admin', and restricted section page types are a standard pattern. On a single-role site where every editor can already edit every page, the boundary does not exist and there is no additional impact — hence Medium, not High, in the general case. Where the boundary exists, this is a cross-boundary tree-restructuring and protected-sibling-mutation bypass.

Impact
A user with no create/edit rights over a restricted page-type subtree can:

  • Relocate a page they control into that restricted subtree (placing their content beneath an admin-only/role-gated section, changing its URL/slug to inherit the protected branch's path, and altering site structure across an authorization boundary), and
  • Cause an unchecked updateMany to re-rank the restricted parent's existing children — i.e. mutate (reorder) documents the actor is explicitly not permitted to edit.

This is an integrity / authorization-boundary violation. It does not, by itself, disclose restricted field contents (read access is still filtered elsewhere) — confidentiality impact is None — and it is not a remote code or availability bug. The security consequence is unauthorized modification of protected content structure/ordering and unauthorized placement of content inside a role-gated branch.

Severity

Medium Basis: The source's own band: MODERATE

Dates

Published
2026-09-03 20:05 UTC
Modified
2026-09-03 20:15 UTC

Affected packages and fixes

apostrophe

npm · All systems

Affected

  • introduced 0, fixed 4.32.0 (semver)

Fixed versions

4.32.0

Fix

Fix commands are the export's own generic commands. Ojuju never runs them. Check them against your setup first.

Check your own computer: guard packages check

View this record on OSV.dev

Source

Source: GitHub Advisory Database (reviewed advisories) · CC BY 4.0

Sources & licences